Evaluative vs. Facilitative Mediation: Why Preparation Gets Cases Settled in One Day

In my experience, as a mediator and as a party representative, cases settle on the day of mediation more often when the mediator has prepared with counsel in advance and is willing to give the parties a candid assessment of their case. For years, the trend in mediation training has been toward the facilitative model, and that model has real value, but, perhaps appropriately, in practice facilitative mediation continues to take a back seat to the evaluative model. Too often mediations have become a long day of carrying offers between rooms, with no one testing whether either side's expectations are realistic. The inability of a mediator to shift to the evaluative model, when needed and warranted, results in mediations that run into a second day, a continued session, or weeks of follow-up calls.
The Two Approaches
A facilitative mediator manages the process and leaves the merits to the parties. The mediator asks questions, helps each side identify its interests, carries offers between rooms, and avoids telling anyone how the case is likely to turn out. The idea is that parties are more committed to a resolution they reach on their own.
An evaluative mediator does all of that and also gives the parties an assessment of the case: the strengths and weaknesses of each side's position, the likely range of outcomes at trial, and what it will cost in time, money and risk to get there. Done well, that assessment is delivered privately, in caucus, and is grounded in the facts and the law. It is not a tactic for moving numbers.
Most experienced mediators use both. The framework many of us learned, Professor Leonard Riskin's “grid” from the 1990s, describes the two approaches as ends of a spectrum. That is how it works in practice. The question is where on the spectrum a mediator starts, and how willing and able the mediator is to move.
Training vs. Practice
Mediation training has long emphasized the facilitative model, and it is still the approach most new mediators are taught. Civil practice has moved in a different direction. Much of the work now happens in caucus, with the parties in separate rooms and the mediator moving between them. A survey published in 2021 of more than 1,000 mediators in eight states, including California, found that most civil mediations still open in joint session, but that those sessions “often are a shadow of their traditional selves” (Wissler & Hinshaw 2021). The same article reports a survey of JAMS mediators in which 80% said they regularly began in joint session when they started practicing, compared with 45% at the time of the survey.
Caucus is not the problem. Used well, it is where the most productive conversations happen. The problem arises when the mediator becomes a messenger, carrying numbers from one room to the other without engaging with the merits. That is neither facilitative mediation, which works on the parties' interests, nor evaluative mediation, which tests their positions. Each side's view of its case can survive the entire day intact. The parties trade numbers, the gap closes slowly, and at 6:00 p.m. everyone agrees to continue the discussion.
I am not aware of any study that tracks how long mediations last over time, so I offer this as an observation from my own practice: more mediations are scheduled for two days, or continued after a full first day. Some of that reflects more complex cases. A continued mediation is not a failure, and some cases need one. But it costs the clients another day of fees for counsel and the mediator, positions harden in the interim, and the momentum that builds over a long day of negotiation is hard to rebuild on a later date.
Why Evaluation and Preparation Help Cases Settle the Same Day
In my experience, an evaluative approach backed by real preparation resolves more cases before the parties leave the building. There are four reasons.
Both sides arrive better prepared. Without a substantive pre-mediation call, each side can arrive having focused mostly on the strengths of its own case. A pre-mediation call can focus counsel on any gaps in their respective facts and the law, so they are better prepared to address issues raised by opposing counsel, which makes the first caucus very productive. The remaining hours are then spent negotiating, not waiting for each side to adjust.
A neutral view adds to counsel's advice. A substantive pre-mediation call gives counsel time to work through newly identified strengths and weaknesses in their case with their clients before the mediation, so no one is surprised on the day. Counsel can also let me know where a neutral's view would be most useful. At the mediation, the parties then hear an assessment from a neutral who has no stake in the outcome, and can weigh it alongside the advice of their own counsel.
Credibility depends on preparation. An evaluation from a mediator who skimmed the brief that morning carries little weight. One grounded in the pleadings, the key documents and the applicable law does. Parties can tell the difference within the first few minutes.
Obstacles surface before the mediation. Insurance consent, lienholders, tax treatment, payment timing, confidentiality and other non-monetary terms can stall a deal at the end of the day. Pre-mediation calls bring those issues out early, so they are addressed before they become a reason to adjourn.
The research on mediator style is mixed, and much of it is admittedly dated. One study of civil court mediations found settlement in 69% of cases where the mediator used an evaluative strategy, compared with 28% where the mediator stayed neutral (Wall, Dunne & Chan-Serafin 2011). The research on preparation is more consistent: settlement is more likely the more thoroughly counsel prepare their clients (Wissler 2002).
What the Preparation Looks Like
The work done before the mediation day is what makes an evaluation useful. In my practice, it has three parts.
Mediation briefs in advance. I ask for briefs ahead of the session. Whether they are exchanged or kept confidential is up to counsel. Either way, I read them closely, along with the cases and statutes cited and the key documents, so I come in with a working view of each side's case.
Pre-mediation calls with counsel. I hold a separate call with each side's counsel before every mediation. The calls are as much about building trust in the process as gathering information, and I avoid turning them into an early round of negotiation. We typically cover:
what is driving the dispute beyond the money;
what each side hopes to achieve at the mediation;
what additional legal research or factual support should be briefed prior to the mediation;
where counsel think a neutral's view would be most useful;
the history of any prior settlement discussions;
potential obstacles such as liens, insurance, tax or timing; and
whether a joint session will help or hurt.
A draft settlement agreement. When possible, I prepare a skeletal draft settlement agreement before the mediation, and then continue to build it out as deal points fall into place. If the case resolves, the parties leave with a signed agreement instead of a term sheet that still has to be negotiated. Deals that are left to be papered later have a way of coming apart.
Where Facilitative Mediation Still Belongs
Evaluation is a tool, and it is not the right tool for every case or every moment. A facilitative approach often works better in four situations:
The parties have an ongoing relationship. Business partners, family members in a closely held company, and the neighbors and board members in a homeowners association may need to work together after the case is over. Helping them find a resolution they own can matter more than a quick number.
A party needs to be heard first. When emotions are driving the dispute, an early evaluation can feel dismissive and harden a position. Listening first earns the credibility an evaluation needs later.
The parties have already evaluated the case. The parties and their counsel may already have a realistic view of the risks. What they need is help closing the gap.
The parties ask for it. The style of the mediation should be driven by the parties. If the parties and their counsel prefer that I not offer an assessment, I don't.
In practice, many of my mediations start facilitative and become evaluative when the negotiation stalls. The skill lies in knowing when to make that shift.
Getting the Most Out of the Mediation Day
Counsel can do a great deal to make a single day of mediation enough. Send the brief early. Take the pre-mediation call and use it to tell the mediator what matters most to your client. And make sure the people with real settlement authority, including any insurance representative, will be in the room.
Facilitative mediation will remain an important part of the process. But a mediator who prepares, engages with the merits, and is willing to give each side a candid assessment gives the parties their best chance of resolving the case in one day.
Sources
Leonard L. Riskin, Understanding Mediators' Orientations, Strategies, and Techniques: A Grid for the Perplexed, 1 Harv. Negot. L. Rev. 7 (1996).
James A. Wall, Timothy C. Dunne & Suzanne Chan-Serafin, The Effects of Neutral, Evaluative, and Pressing Mediator Strategies, 29 Conflict Resol. Q. 127 (2011).
Roselle L. Wissler, Court-Connected Mediation in General Civil Cases: What We Know from Empirical Research, 17 Ohio St. J. on Disp. Resol. 641 (2002).
Roselle L. Wissler & Art Hinshaw, The Initial Mediation Session: An Empirical Examination, 27 Harv. Negot. L. Rev. 1 (2021).
Eric Sternberger is a mediator with Sternberger ADR Solutions in San Rafael, California, and a partner at Ragghianti Freitas LLP. He has mediated business, real estate, and homeowners association disputes since 2008 and serves on the Marin County Superior Court settlement conference panel. He can be reached at info@sternberger-adr.com or 415.526.0108.

Comments